COLOURED STATIC PRESS / GAME REVIEWS / THE STORY OF A GUNFIGHT
In the supernatural West, a good plan can win a shootout. A great plan lets you start another before your enemies have worked out what happened. Unfortunately, the ones hiding in corners didn’t get the memo.
REVIEW SCORE87/100
An enemy falls. Our Action Points return. And the turn that seemed almost finished suddenly has a second act. Hard West 2 knows exactly how to make a tactical gunfight exciting: it rewards the plan you made by inviting you to make another before the dust has settled.
Before that shot, there had been calculations: who to target, where to position the posse and which opening might leave enough momentum for another attack. On paper, it was a sensible set of decisions. On the battlefield, when everything clicked into place, it felt like we’d briefly managed to outsmart the entire Wild West.
One more move. One more shot. Perhaps another enemy who was about to have a very unfortunate afternoon.
That is the hook at the heart of this supernatural Western adventure. Hard West 2 combines turn-based tactical battles with a story about Gin Carter and his posse, but it is the way a successful attack can create the next opportunity that gives its gunfights such momentum. You aren’t merely trying to survive the current exchange. You’re looking for the opening that might change the entire encounter.
The fine art of starting another gunfight
Killing an enemy restores Action Points, allowing a well-planned turn to continue. It’s a simple idea with a delicious consequence: the first target you choose isn’t necessarily the biggest threat, but the one whose defeat might make everything else possible.
Positioning matters. Target order matters. So does having the discipline to think beyond the gunshot you’re about to take. Charging in with the confidence of an outlaw who has never considered the possibility of being wrong isn’t quite the strategy it appears to be.
When the pieces line up, though, the combat is terrific. A successful elimination feels like a reward in itself, but the returned Action Points transform it into an opportunity. The accompanying sound effect makes that moment even better. There is something wonderfully encouraging about a game audibly congratulating you for making a good decision, particularly when the next decision might be even better.
The difficulty generally strikes a good balance. Careful thinking gave us a fighting chance, but the Shadow Clan was more than willing to challenge our confidence. Encounters demanded attention without making every mistake feel like a personal insult from the developers. Most of the time, we could look at a difficult situation and imagine a way through it. We just needed to find the right sequence.
There’s always somebody you didn’t see
Of course, there is one thing that can ruin an otherwise excellent tactical plan: discovering the battlefield has neglected to tell you where all the enemies are.
On a few occasions, a fight appeared to be winding down, only for another opponent to seemingly materialise from nowhere. We also struggled to see enemies positioned in certain corners, particularly when controlling other members of the posse. Sometimes the problem wasn’t deciding what to do. It was working out who was still there to do it to.
This matters more in Hard West 2 than it might in a looser action game. When combat rewards planning several actions ahead, obscured opponents make the information you’re relying on less trustworthy. It’s a little like trying to play chess while somebody occasionally hides one of the pieces under a hat. You can still win, but you’d rather know where the bishop has gone.
These moments weren’t frequent enough to undermine the fighting, and they didn’t erase the satisfaction of a well-executed turn. They did, however, interrupt a system that is at its best when the challenge comes from making decisions, not from struggling to see the available choices.
A posse is more than the sum of its revolvers
We came for the tactical gunfights. The posse gave us another reason to stay.
As Gin Carter’s story unfolded, the relationships between companions began to matter beyond their immediate usefulness in battle. Building loyalty became an investment of its own, and we found ourselves resisting the temptation to favour a handful of characters. Instead, we tried to earn everyone’s loyalty as evenly as possible.
It sounds almost suspiciously considerate for a gang operating in a supernatural Wild West. Still, there is something appealing about wanting the entire group to feel involved, rather than treating companions as a selection of spare firearms.
That investment also spills into exploration. The map’s question marks continually tempted us away from the main objective, each one promising another discovery. Some encounters required the right tools or a particular level of loyalty with a posse member, so not every detour could be resolved on the spot.
We liked that. It made the landscape feel less like a string of errands and more like a place full of opportunities we weren’t always ready to take. Finding something we couldn’t yet access was frustrating in the useful way: it gave us a reason to remember it and wonder what might be waiting when we returned.
A West with something wrong in the shadows
Hard West 2 also understands the value of atmosphere. Its dark environments, detailed tactical battlefields and illustrated storytelling sequences give the adventure a supernatural identity without losing the appeal of a Western.
The music and sound effects carry much of that mood. There is a darkness to the soundtrack that fits the setting, while the gunfights have the impact they need to make each successful attack feel consequential. And that little audio reward when an enemy falls and the Action Points return? We could become very fond of hearing it.
But the atmosphere would mean far less without a story worth pursuing. We found ourselves increasingly invested in Gin Carter’s companions, their loyalties and the questions the narrative had yet to answer. In particular, the mystery of a missing posse member remains firmly on our list of unfinished business.
That is a good place for a review to be: not pretending that every mystery has been solved, but genuinely interested in what the next chapter might reveal.
The verdict: one more shot, one more chapter
The best thing about Hard West 2 is that its tactical combat has a sense of occasion. A kill restores your Action Points, a good sequence becomes a great turn, and suddenly the entire fight feels as though it might turn on one clever decision. The Shadow Clan provides an entertaining challenge, while Gin Carter’s posse and the loyalty system give the journey more emotional weight than a series of disconnected gunfights would have.
The occasional trouble spotting enemies in corners is a genuine frustration, especially in a game that asks you to think so carefully about the battlefield. But it is an interruption to an excellent system rather than a reason to dismiss it. Between the combat, exploration and wonderfully grim atmosphere, this is an adventure we want to return to.
87/100 · EXCELLENT. We still have a missing posse member to find, several question marks to investigate and, presumably, more trouble waiting with the Shadow Clan. Next time, we’ll bring a better plan. And perhaps check the corners twice.
Review: Coloured Static Press Editorial. Based on original team-submitted gameplay observations. Score in submitted review: 87/100.







