INDEPENDENT GAMES, TECH & CULTURE ♡ Support the Press

MORE SIGNAL. LESS NOISE.

COLOURED STATIC PRESS / ORIGINAL COVERAGE

, , ,

Cauldron Chaos Review | Potion Brewing, Vanishing Mushrooms and a Very Messy Shop (87/100)

Cauldron Chaos official key art87/100EXCELLENT

Coloured Static Press / Game Reviews / Hands-on review

Our potion shop is a disaster, the mushrooms have gone into hiding, and somebody has put the brewing instructions on a need-to-know basis. Somehow, Cauldron Chaos: Brew Potions & Tidy Up makes that a rather lovely way to spend an afternoon.

COLOURED STATIC PRESS
REVIEW SCORE
87/100

There are two sorts of people in the world: those who see a cluttered room and walk straight back out, and those who immediately start organising the contents. Cauldron Chaos is very much for the second group. It deposits you in a magical shop overflowing with ingredients and unfinished business, then lets you sort out the mess while brewing increasingly elaborate potions.

After around three hours with the game, we were still finding reasons to rummage through the shelves. There’s something deeply satisfying about taking a shop that looks as if a wizard has lost an argument with a skip and slowly turning it into a functioning alchemy business.

Gameplay screenshot showing the colourful alchemy shop in Cauldron Chaos
The shop is cluttered, colourful and rather more ambitious than its opening instructions suggest. Gameplay screenshot.

A recipe book, a lever and a slightly optimistic tutorial

Getting started takes more trial and error than it should. You’re handed a recipe book and told to brew potions, but the game is reluctant to explain the important details. Ingredients have to enter the cauldron in the right order, and even then, you must find the lever that actually starts the brewing. Some clearer early guidance would have saved a good deal of staring at a pot and wondering whether it was judging us.

Once those basics click, however, the layout starts to make sense. Preparation stations for chopping, crystallising, distilling and pulverising are easy to identify and conveniently placed. There’s plenty of work to do, but very little need to run laps around the building just to prepare one ingredient.

Gameplay screenshot of the ingredient preparation area in Cauldron Chaos
A little preparation goes a long way when the recipes begin to demand more than three ingredients. Gameplay screenshot.

The potion-making gets cleverer as you go

Early recipes require only three ingredients, introduced one at a time. As you progress, more complex mixtures demand components you’ve already brewed. Higher-tier and ultimate recipes turn the process into a pleasing chain of smaller tasks rather than a matter of tossing random things into a pot and hoping for the best.

Fortunately, mistakes aren’t ruinous. Brew with the wrong ingredients and the cauldron simply spits them out. It’s mildly embarrassing, particularly when the rejected bits disappear back into the clutter, but at least nothing precious has been lost. Better still, the Deconstructing Void can undo prepared ingredients and potions, restoring them to their original state. Every crafting game that encourages experimentation ought to have such a civilised way of saying, “No, actually, let’s not.”

Cauldron Chaos gameplay screenshot featuring the crystallising station
The preparation stations give potion-making a useful sense of process, rather than making every recipe an identical button press. Gameplay screenshot.

The mushroom is the real final boss

Finding the ingredients can be more troublesome than using them. With so much clutter on the floor, small objects disappear beneath the larger ones. Several almost-black, flat mushrooms proved particularly determined to remain undiscovered. There are magical spells to help, including one that gathers the components for a recipe, although lengthy cooldowns stop them from becoming a permanent solution.

The wand you use to move ingredients and completed potions is usually straightforward to handle. Objects do occasionally catch on shelves and surrounding clutter, but it’s also possible to fling troublesome items across the shop when diplomacy has failed. We cannot promise our potion shop would pass a workplace safety inspection.

Gameplay screenshot showing a magical ingredient in Cauldron Chaos
Hunting down every ingredient is occasionally harder than preparing it. Gameplay screenshot.

Bright colours and little magical details

The cheerful, cartoon-like fantasy presentation makes the shop a pleasant place to spend time. Its upbeat soundtrack suits the busy atmosphere, while little effects, especially the satisfying noise when the wand lifts an object, make the basic interactions enjoyable. These things matter in a game where you’ll be repeating many of the same motions.

There are rough edges, principally the limited introduction and occasional fiddliness when moving objects. Neither was enough to overwhelm the fun of learning the systems, improving the shop and filling the shelves with finished concoctions.

Who knew turning a magical disaster area into an organised potion shop could be so satisfying?

The verdict: 87/100

Cauldron Chaos: Brew Potions & Tidy Up is a charming and surprisingly absorbing crafting-and-organisation game. Its escalating recipes, forgiving experiments and useful spells build a rewarding loop, supported by a colourful presentation and small but satisfying details. It could explain itself better at the beginning, and the ingredient pile occasionally becomes its own puzzle, but we still have shelves to fill. We’ll be back.

Best for: players who enjoy collecting, crafting, organising and cleaning up somebody else’s magical catastrophe.

Review by Coloured Static Press Editorial. Approximately three hours of hands-on gameplay. Images show genuine in-game material; no AI-generated artwork used. Score: 87/100.


← Back to the latest stories