COLOURED STATIC PRESS / EDITORIAL TRANSPARENCY
We use a 100-point editorial score for completed game and hardware reviews. The Signal Profile gives readers a clearer look at the thinking behind the verdict, using the distinctive static-line language of the Coloured Static Press identity. It is built with real HTML and CSS, not AI-generated review artwork.
The number at the centre is our considered editorial judgement, reached after the hands-on work described in the review. It is not an arithmetic average. Four supporting categories can explain particular strengths and weaknesses, but a category only receives a number when our team has actually assessed it.
Our score and verdict bands
| Score | Verdict | How we use it |
|---|---|---|
| 95–100 | Masterpiece | Rare and genre-defining. |
| 90–94 | Outstanding | Essential and exceptionally executed. |
| 85–89 | Exceptional | A genuine must-play or must-own experience. |
| 80–84 | Excellent | A strong recommendation with minor reservations. |
| 70–79 | Very good | Enjoyable or well made, with shortcomings. |
| 60–69 | Good ideas | Significant strengths with notable limitations. |
| 1–59 | Mixed to poor | Read the written verdict for the reasons and limits. |
These are the official game and hardware bands used in our Editorial Standards. Tabletop and hobby coverage uses a separate assessment framework appropriate to the activity.
Four categories, tailored to what we review
| Games | Hardware |
|---|---|
| Gameplay · Controls, design and the experience of playing. | Build & Design · Construction, ergonomics, materials and fit. |
| Presentation · Art, audio, clarity and the finished presentation. | Performance · Relevant measured results and transparently described real-world behaviour. |
| Depth & Variety · Meaningful systems, content and lasting appeal. | Features & Usability · Compatibility, software, practicality and ease of use. |
| Polish & Performance · Stability, responsiveness, accessibility and avoidable friction. | Value · The benefits, shortcomings and credible alternatives at the available UK price. |
See The Signal Profile in action
Design demonstration only. Both scorecards below use fictional example ratings to show how the layout works. They are not verdicts on actual games or products and should not be quoted as reviews.
Games example
Games / ReviewThe Signal Profile
- Gameplay85
- Presentation86
- Depth & Variety82
- Polish & Performance83
The final score is an editorial judgement, not a simple average.
Hardware example
Hardware Lab / ReviewThe Signal Profile
- Build & Design88
- Performance87
- Features & Usability86
- Value85
The final score is an editorial judgement, not a simple average.
Evidence before presentation
We do not estimate missing playtime, invent benchmarks or assign retrospective category ratings simply to fill a graphic. Older reviews may retain their existing overall score without four new category numbers. Previews and early impressions remain unscored until there is enough evidence to support a completed review.
Reviews are credited to Coloured Static Press Editorial. Review copies, loaned equipment and relevant commercial relationships are disclosed, and none can purchase a score or favourable verdict. See our Review Policy and How We Test Hardware for the detailed process.
